Skip to content

Italy Government on Verge of Collapse as Renzi Party Quits

    Ex-premier says Conte not doing enough to fix country’s issues

    Resignation triggers crisis with no clear solution in sight

    By Chiara Albanese and John Follain January 14, 2021, 4:20 AM GMT+11 Updated on January 14, 2021, 6:47 AM GMT+11

    Former Prime Minister Matteo Renzi  Photographer: Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

    Italy’s government led by Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte risks collapsing in the middle of the Covid-19 pandemic after a junior coalition partner pulled out.

    Former Premier Matteo Renzi said his Italy Alive party is quitting the coalition, attacking Conte for failing to do enough to tackle the country’s problems. Though the party is tiny, Conte relies on it to maintain his majority in parliament.

    Renzi’s decision sparks a government crisis which could last days or even weeks, and has no clear solution in sight.

    After accepting the ministers’ resignation, Conte could step down himself. That would likely trigger a new round of talks among parties and lead to another Conte government, a new premier or a technocratic administration. Snap elections, although a risk, appear unlikely for now.

    ‘Act of Courage’

    Pulling out at a such a crucial moment for the country amounts to “an act of courage,” Renzi said at a news conference in Rome. Conte’s government has not done enough to resolve problems from education to infrastructure, as well as the virus, the ex-premier said.

    “We are not playing,” Renzi said, addressing critics who’ve accused his party of political posturing during weeks of build-up to the current crisis. “Democracy is not a reality show.”

    Investors have reacted to the heightened uncertainty. German bund futures rose about 20 ticks to their highest of the day after the announcement, while Italy Treasury bond futures fell. The cost of borrowing for the Italian government has risen modestly in recent days on concerns of political instability.

    Italian bond yields have spiked higher on fears of Renzi departure

    The timing of the crisis for Conte could hardly be worse, with Italy battling a worsening pandemic and a recession. A cabinet meeting scheduled for Wednesday at 8:30 p.m. is due to discuss new virus-related restrictions, while on Thursday Conte is set to sign off on a plan to widen the country’s deficit by about 24 billion euros ($29 billion).

    Renzi said that his party is still willing to back plans for more deficit spending and any measures necessary to tackle the pandemic. He didn’t rule out a new government led by Conte but said Italy Alive won’t support any coalition including Matteo Salvini’s League, an anti-migrant, anti-EU opposition party.

    Nicola Zingaretti, head of the ruling Democratic Party, said Renzi’s move was a “huge mistake.”

    Presidential Role

    With Renzi’s two ministers now exiting the government, the focus turns to President Sergio Mattarella, who met with Conte earlier Wednesday. The president’s role, largely ceremonial, also includes responsibilities for safeguarding the country’s political stability.

    If Conte opts to resign, he could be given a mandate by Mattarella to try to forge a new alliance.

    Alternatively, the premier could seek a parliamentary vote of confidence. But if he fails to win over enough centrist and unaffiliated lawmakers to replace Renzi’s Italy Alive, the government would become a caretaker administration with limited powers.

    Read more: Conte’s Options to Prevent Ally From Toppling Italy’s Government

    The existing coalition parties — including Italy Alive — could also try to revive their alliance under a different premier, such as ex-European Central Bank President Mario Draghi. They’ll likely explore a range of options to avoid a new election, as surveys show the Salvini-led center-right would likely win if the country is forced into a snap vote.

    ”The impact of Renzi’s move on Italy’s fragile economy will depend on what will happen next,” said Lorenzo Pregliasco, a political analyst at YouTrend. “A snap vote, the worst scenario for investors, remains unlikely at this stage.”

    Unfinished Business

    The crisis couldn’t come at a worst time for Italy. Here’s what’s at stake if Conte’s government loses its support in parliament.

    Renzi had been dialing up the pressure on Conte since late last year, slamming the prime minister’s plans for managing and spending European Union rescue funds. Renzi says the plan has been improved following his demands, but he’s been insisting on further conditions, including that Italy tap a European Stability Mechanism credit line for health spending.

    “The real issue is, should we spend more money on health with the ESM?” Renzi said following his announcement on Wednesday.

    — With assistance by Marco Bertacche

    Chiara Albanese

    John Follain

    Leave a Comment